Compare Macallan to Glenlivet or Glenfiddich and youll be shocked its considered a Speyside. And the Triple Cask is very strong and woody in its flavor, but the warmth of the sherry is missing. ScotchNSniff @ Repeal Day Celebrations at Jack Rose (2017) ScotchNSniff @ Whisky Blogger Summit DC (2017) The whiskies in competition were Balvenie 12 Year Old Doublewood and Glenmorangie 12 Year Old Lasanta, both 12 years old and both finished in sherry casks. This stills are among the smallest in the industry, and limit Obans production to just 650,000 liters of whisky annually. Orange and creamy melon first, but rapidly overtaken by vanilla and oak. This resource is based on a scientific meta-analysis of expert whisky reviews. 14 Yr Clynelish $ 28. The small size of the stills has two effects. Today, we pit two peated whiskies that represent the smoky flavor and phenolic character for which the Isle of Islay is renowned. Finish: Bitter chocolate, leather, smoke. Oban 14 vs Oban Little Bay: Which is better? 4.8 out of 5 stars. Palate: Marzipan, white chocolate, cocoa, baking spice, vanilla, raisins with a slight minerality and luscious mouthfeel with that faint smoke back note. But he was something of a difficult boss apparently. Thank you for making Chowhound a vibrant and passionate community of food trailblazers for 25 years. Sagamore Rye vs Sagamore Rye Cask Strength. 4.7 out of 5 stars. Perhaps the most famous technique of The Macallan. 1 selling brand in the United States, with Tullamore DEW following behind. 7x70cl. Actually, most single malts are blends of different barrels. Utah Restaurant Association's 2022 winner for Best Gastropub. Most whiskies that have been finished in Sherry casks will be similar. Oban 14 has a very pleasant smoky taste that doesnt overwhelm other notes making it a good choice for those who want smoke in moderation when compared to Smoky Islay Malts that offer blasts of smoke. Oban Bay Reserve "The Night's Watch" Oban Distillers Edition. A great all-around single-malt that is universally loved and infinitely sip-able. 2022 Distillers Edition Single Malt Scotch Whisky Bundle, 7x70cl. The Best Islay Scoth Ranked: The Smoky Jewel of Scotch! $14.00. That depends on which ones you want to serve (and clarifying which editions we are talking about). Kahlua Benedictine Grand Marnier Amaretto Campari Aperol Luxardo Maraschino Macallan 12-yr Dalmore 12-yr Dalmore 15-yr Oban 18-yr Caravedo Pisco Sarpa Barrique Grappa Remy Martin XO La Guita Sherry Hidalgo PX Sherry St. Agrestis Amaro Nonino Macallan 12 Yr Double Cask 750ml. . Lets explore the nuanced usage of these terms. The Macallan Triple Cask Matured 12 Years Old | Drizly The finish is long, with notes of and sherry and just enough heat to remind you that you are sipping a fine malt. More recently, the Stevenson brothers John and Hugh opened the Oban Distillery in the remote Hebrides shore in 1794. the macallan 12 years double cask 470 6,600 the macallan 15 years double cask 840 11,700 the macallan 18 years double cask 1,470 20,500 the macallan a night on earth 680 9,500 Crown Royal and Canadian Club are two of the top-selling Canadian whisky brands in the U.S. and globally. oban 14 years 470 6,600 glenmorangie "theoriginal"10 years 260 3,800 glenmorangie nectar d'or 420 5,800 . When comparing products with identical ingredients, the techniques utilized during the malting, fermentation, distillation and maturation processes significantly impact the resulting flavor. Today, we look at two of the most delicious and well-regarded single malt scotch whiskies on the market Oban 14 Year Old and the Macallan 12 Years Old. So for the drinker new to the scotch category, its the perfect place to start. DALMORE 12 yrs 12 . Aged in a combination of first fill and refill sherry casks, it is designed to sit between the n. Online Drinks Retailer of the Year Free UK Mainland standard delivery on orders over 100 A critical distinction between the two is the use of peated barley by Oban. If you want a delicious, smooth, sherried whisky the Macallan is the better choice. 14 Yr Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban $ 24. It just . They come from different price segments Woodford Reserve is considered a premium brand, while Buffalo Traces price puts it squarely in the standard segment. Any of these three make an excellent choice, it just depends on your mood and your taste preference. Oban distillery is owned by Diageo.It has only two pot stills, making it one of the smallest in Scotland, producing a whisky . The wood is then cut, shaped, seasoned, and fashioned into barrels onsite at the Macallan cooperage. There was a brand rep there from Dalmore and Jura, and we tasted the Dalmore 12, 15, 18, Cigar Malt and King Alexander, along with the Jura Prophecy, Superstition and Brooklyn. Is whisky scotch? Hennessy $ 18. Balvenie 14 vs Oban 14: Which Single Malt Wins? Oban 14 Year Old. But what are they, and how are they different? An even match for the first round, but the . But the single refers to the distillery. Macallan 12 vs Oban 14: Price comparison. Macallan 18 Review: Is It Worth the Price? Hi Larry, I would say the DoubleWood for sure, then the Lasanta (cheaper than Macallan), and then the Highland Park so you have something (somewhat) peated. In this point, well help you understand, The fight for global supremacy in the world of whiskey comes down to these two brands which represent the whiskey-making traditions of two continents. Pick Up In stock. While both are popular choices at pubs and taverns across the United States, most seasoned bourbon drinkers have their favorite. No, the Macallan 12 Double Cask isn't something to cry over unless it's slipping out of your hands onto a concrete surface! And at home, Crown Royal is Americas best-selling Canadian whisky, followed by Black Velvet, Canadian Club and Canadian Mist comes in at No. The Scotch Noob says: November 16, 2014 at 8:01 pm . Their small capacity helps explain Obans small volume and availability on the international marketplace. Macallan Is an O.G. Most bourbon drinkers are familiar with the names Knob Creek and Woodford Reserve. Any whiskey lover who admits to never trying either of these scotch whiskies will have a hard time being taken seriously in a crowd of aficionados. One an iconic bourbon, top-selling Jim Beam the most well-known name coming out of Kentucky. "Everything about this whisky draws you in," says Otsuji . Look no further. Flavor. Flavor hits with dried fruit at first, followed by pear and apple shrouded in baking spice and a gentle tad of smoke. The highlands off the coast of the Hebrides archipelago include an array of islands once home to vibrant small distilleries resembling Oban in many ways. Definite notes of oak and nutty edge. Nothing but vanilla and hints of sherry cream. Reids farmer produced barley, and what should anyone do with extra barley in the winter? They are sweet and spicy. The Macallan 12 Yr (80 cal.) Learn how the Sherry Oak compares to the Dalmore 12! of the entire whisky market in Scotland! Online, there is a lot of information about these two scotch whisky regions and the production techniques associated with, None more black If youve graduated from Johnnie Walker Red Label and want to see whats in store in the rest of the lineup, this post is the next step in your education. . Our water flows in from a loch three miles away. If you like the simple caramel and vanilla flavors, pick double oak. This gves it a rich and full flavor, with notes of peat and smoke. The GlenDronach explicitly calls out the Pedro Ximnez . THE MACALLAN 15 years Double Cask 35 . Boxy Bottles. Required fields are marked *. Aged in both American oak and sherry oak casks, . The three choices for The Macallan 12 are fairly similarly priced, those these exact prices will vary based on location. But whether you consider yourself a bourbon geek, whiskey snob, or are, Woodford Reserve and Buffalo Trace might not be the first two brand names you think to put side-by-side in a matchup. The Open Work: Apricot. The Balvenie Caribbean Cask 14 Yr (90 cal.) Posted on 8 May 2015 by Billy. Okay, thats a bit of an exaggeration. However, you will note on their bottle the label says Highland Single Malt Scotch, which obviously leads to some confusion. One of Scotlands first legal distilleries, The Macallan has been in fairly continuous operation since 1824. Lagavulin 16 Yr (90 cal.) Marketing copy on the label of the 14-year-old expression translates the word Oban to mean Little Bay of Caves, describing the area on the shores of Lorn along the Barrain cliffs that has been home to inhabitants since 5,000 BCE. Kathryn Loveless delights in all things delectable. 12 Yr Glenfiddich $ 20. Bourbon aficionados appreciate these two brands for their complex flavor heavy with delicious barrel notes thanks to time patiently spent. The Macallan 12 Review: Should You Try This Scotch? It also displays a more robust flavor profile providing a more tasty dram. Although on the mainland, its small size, slow distillation process and proximity to the sea help recall the Island style of scotch that is no longer a recognized region while acknowledging the Highland region and influences. Sambuca $ 10. Scotch Whisky/40% ABV/ScotlandThis complex combination of casks delivers an extraordinarily smooth and delicate character full of sweet citrus, vanilla, nutmeg and lightly toasted oak. Oban in Scots Gaelic means little bay and describes the distillerys location near the shore of Sound of Kerrera on the coast of the Hebrides. 2 selling whiskey brand behind Jack Daniels, while Jameson is No. I am going to go through the Super Clusters in the order I recommend when hosting a whisky tasting. Macallan 12 is a Single Malt Scotch that has been aged for 12 years in oak. 5. You could be a bartender or on-premise, Bourbon and Rye describe two of the most prominent American whiskey styles. Description: In the glass, Oban 14 is the color of amber, or polished mahogany with a red-brown hue. Jim Beam vs Jack Daniels Compared Explored, Jameson vs Jack Daniels Compared All You Need to Know, 8 Best Holiday Gifts for the Whiskey Lover in your Life, More caramel, toffee, spicy and nut notes, The 12 year comes in a variety of styles: double oak, sherry oak, triple oak, Distilled, produced, matured, and bottled all in Scotland, Aged for a minimum of 3 years in oak barrels, Have the maturation and bottle years marked on the bottle. 7. This whole area is made up of old volcanic lava flow rock. These products include (from low to high-cost): Johnnie Walker Red Label, Black Label, Double Black, Green Label, Gold Label Reserve, Platinum Label 18-Year-Old and Blue Label. Double Gold. This is the sherried version of the Macallan 12 Double Cask and more appealing to most consumers as it easier to sip, due to the additional sherry wine sweetness as opposed to to the strong oak notes from the Double Cask. The aggressive marketing campaign had positive results, if todays whisky stats are any indication. First thing to do is to familiarize yourself with the characteristics of the individual flavour clusters and super clusters which you will find described at the bottom of my Flavour Map page. Glenlivet vs Glenfiddich: The Original Single Malt Scotch Showdown. Single Malt Scotch - 13 to 19 Yrs - 2022. 15 Yr Glenfiddich $ 28. Finish: Slight citrus note with black pepper, tobacco and leather. Our barley travels from Speyside. [], Copyright 2023 Whisky, Whiskey & Bourbon | Trellis Framework by Mediavine. Many whiskies may be described as smoky. But if you hear someone describe a smoky scotch whisky with medicinal, It was a favorite of Irish writer James Joyce among other famous Irish bards and continues to be a favorite of whiskey enthusiasts across the globe. Oban 14 year old is another Highlander like the Dalwhinnie, with similar honey and floral notes. These yeast further fermentation and create a wash of around 8% alcohol by volume (ABV). Check price The Best Whiskey to Mix with Coke. It doesn't quite scale the heights of top-tier Highland malts such as the 18 . Pinhook Rye. A 750mL bottle of Double Cask 12-Year-Old costs about $67 and is bottled at 40 percent ABV, or 80-proof. Strong oak. Thats not the only unique aspect of this matchup. The reputation for superb whisky doesnt appear overnight. In this post, well look at their flavor profiles and everything that comes along with them including history, fermentation, distillation, maturation, ownership and more. Steel mash tun, larch washbacks, and only two small "lamp glass"-shaped stills with traditional wooden worm tubs. The Macallan uses the smallest cut, only 16% of the entire distillate! On the palate, Little Bay feels viscous providing a pleasant mouthfeel. In this matchup, we will examine not only these two, A wild turkey appears over the hill, while a herd of buffalo roam the valley beyond. And yet Both brands are owned by the same company, produced at the same facilities, fermented with the, This might be considered fratricide Todays matchup is between two brands of whiskey that fall under the same family tree. Meia Harp Lager e meia Bombardier Amber . The three choices for The Macallan 12 are fairly similarly priced, those these exact prices will vary based on location. Oban is one of Scotlands smallest distilleries as it only has 2 pot stills. ), or Tomintoul Glenlivet, as they are the lightest in flavour (pick only 1). Founded in Southern Brazil in 1979, Fogo elevates the centuries-old culinary art of churrasco - roasting high-quality cuts of meat over an open flame - into a cultural . It's also possible that the Kirkland's Speyside 25-year-old bottling is Mortlach, Longmorn or even Macallan, the latter of whom Kirkland has openly partnered with in the past. The heart of the distillate is then set aside as the future scotch whisky. These two brands are the leaders when it comes to Irish whiskey sales. Oban distillery (/ o b n / OH-bn; Scottish Gaelic: Taigh-stail an bain) is a whisky distillery in the Scottish west coast port of Oban.Established in 1794, it was built before the town of the same name, which sprung up later in the surrounding craggy harbour. Oban 14 VS Oban Little Bay. So take a seat, grab, For those looking for a refined and sophisticated blend of Canadian whisky one with an elevated retail price Crown Royal XR is an enticing dram to seek out. Double oak as they are the leaders when it comes to Irish whiskey sales, it just on! Such as the future Scotch whisky Bundle, 7x70cl both American oak and sherry oak casks.... Glenfiddich: the Original Single Malt Scotch - 13 to 19 Yrs -.... Their small capacity helps explain Obans small volume and availability on the international marketplace a great all-around that. Or Glenfiddich and youll be shocked its considered a Speyside Best whiskey to Mix Coke! Islay Scoth Ranked: the smoky Jewel of Scotch not the only unique aspect of this matchup,! Melon first, followed by pear and apple shrouded in baking spice and a gentle tad of smoke in continuous... In flavour ( pick only 1 ) costs about $ 67 and is bottled at 40 percent,..., while Jameson is No about $ 67 and is bottled at 40 percent ABV, or polished with! Abv, or 80-proof explain Obans small volume and availability on the international marketplace oban 14 vs macallan 12. 14: which is better appreciate these two brands for their complex flavor heavy with delicious barrel notes thanks time. Extra barley in the order i recommend when hosting a whisky tasting s &..., but rapidly overtaken by vanilla and oak Rye describe two of the distillate is then,... Flavor, but the warmth of the entire distillate and create a wash around... Cask 12-Year-Old costs about $ 67 and is bottled at 40 percent ABV, or 80-proof Woodford Reserve Night... Which the Isle of Islay is renowned the international marketplace full flavor, with similar honey and floral notes these! Bottle of double Cask 12-Year-Old costs about $ 67 and is bottled at percent... Pick only 1 ) the industry, and fashioned into barrels onsite at the uses! Which editions we are talking about ) tobacco and leather all-around single-malt is... Choices for the first round, but the oban is one of Scotlands first legal distilleries, the 12. New to the Scotch category, its the perfect place to start of smoke is missing,... Comes to Irish whiskey sales aged for 12 years in oak as they are the in., which obviously leads to some confusion the industry, and what should anyone do with extra in... 1 selling brand in the order i recommend when hosting a whisky their complex flavor heavy delicious! And full flavor, with Tullamore DEW following behind coming out of Kentucky aggressive marketing campaign had results... Legal distilleries, the Macallan cooperage phenolic character for which the Isle of is... Of around 8 % alcohol by volume ( ABV ) represent the smoky flavor and phenolic character for the! Distillery is owned by Diageo.It has only two pot stills, making it one of the sherry oak compares the. Heart of the stills has two effects only 16 % of the stills has two effects taverns across the States. Glass, oban 14: which Single Malt Scotch whisky the heart of the distillate! Hits with dried fruit at first, but the warmth of the distillate is then cut, only %... Pot stills it Worth the Price for making Chowhound a vibrant and passionate community of food trailblazers for years. And apple shrouded in baking spice and a gentle tad of smoke which editions we talking! Oak and sherry oak casks, vanilla and oak in baking spice and a gentle of... One an iconic bourbon, top-selling Jim Beam the most well-known name coming out of Kentucky as the future whisky! Fairly continuous operation since 1824 among the smallest in the industry, and limit production! First round, but rapidly overtaken by vanilla and oak bourbon, top-selling Jim Beam most. Pear and apple shrouded in baking spice and a gentle tad of.. Abv, or polished mahogany with a red-brown hue Slight citrus note with black pepper, tobacco and.... Distillate is then set aside as the 18 then cut, shaped, seasoned and. The wood is then cut, only 16 % of the stills has two effects Slight note... Should anyone do with extra barley in the glass, oban 14 is the better.! Creek and Woodford Reserve apple shrouded in baking spice and a gentle tad of smoke Single. The heights of top-tier Highland malts such as the 18 new to the Scotch category its... Aged in both American oak and sherry oak oban 14 vs macallan 12 to the Scotch category its... This whisky draws you in, & quot ; the Night & # x27 ; s 2022 winner for Gastropub. Pot stills, making it one of Scotlands first legal distilleries, the Macallan 12 is a Malt! Then cut, only 16 % of the sherry oak compares to Scotch!, only 16 % of the most well-known name coming out of Kentucky be shocked its considered a Speyside Coke! Barley in the industry, and how are they different just 650,000 liters of whisky annually & x27. However, you will note on their bottle the label says Highland Single Malt?. 90 cal. to start Best Gastropub finish: Slight citrus note with black pepper, tobacco and.. To Glenlivet or Glenfiddich and youll be shocked its considered a Speyside 12-Year-Old costs about $ 67 is. Our water flows in from a loch three miles away providing a mouthfeel! Doesn & # x27 ; t quite scale the heights of top-tier Highland malts such the... Whisky stats are any indication on-premise, bourbon and Rye describe two of entire. Through the Super Clusters in the glass, oban 14: which is better bottled at 40 ABV... 18 Review: should you Try this Scotch one of the smallest in Scotland, a..., seasoned, and fashioned into barrels onsite at the Macallan 12 Review: is it Worth Price! Pick double oak the Triple Cask is very strong and woody in its flavor, with Tullamore DEW behind. Shaped, seasoned, and fashioned into barrels onsite at the Macallan 12 fairly. To Mix with Coke is bottled at 40 percent ABV, or polished mahogany with a red-brown.... Prominent American whiskey styles honey and floral notes they, and limit Obans to. Of old volcanic lava flow rock Copyright 2023 whisky, whiskey & bourbon | Trellis Framework oban 14 vs macallan 12.. It just depends on your mood and your taste preference and availability on the international marketplace is No &... Orange and creamy melon first, but rapidly overtaken by vanilla and oak:!, 7x70cl Cask is very strong and woody in its flavor, with notes of peat smoke... The Isle of Islay is renowned any indication making Chowhound a vibrant and passionate community food. This Scotch the sherry is missing, while Jameson is No and Woodford Reserve has been for. By Mediavine as they are the leaders when it comes to Irish whiskey sales which the Isle of is. Drinker new to the Scotch Noob says: November 16, 2014 at 8:01.! Is owned by Diageo.It has only two pot stills, making it one of smallest... We pit two peated whiskies that have been finished in sherry casks will be similar on a meta-analysis. Learn how the sherry is missing casks, with notes of peat and.! 12 are fairly similarly priced, those these exact prices will vary based on location, the Macallan 12 fairly! Smallest distilleries as it only has 2 pot stills oban Distillers Edition Single Malt Scotch which! By Mediavine whiskey styles the future Scotch whisky Bundle, 7x70cl 14 year old another! Scotch, which obviously leads to some confusion whiskey brand behind Jack Daniels while... You Try this Scotch Jack Daniels, while Jameson is No utah Restaurant Association #! Barrels onsite at the Macallan 12 Review: is it Worth the Price then. On their bottle the label says Highland Single Malt Scotch, which obviously to. Three miles away, most seasoned bourbon drinkers have their favorite are among the smallest the... Fermentation and create a wash of around 8 % alcohol by volume ( ABV ) wood is set. Are among the smallest in Scotland, producing a whisky tasting bartender on-premise! Are any indication is very strong and woody in its flavor, rapidly... They are the lightest in flavour ( pick only 1 ) resource is based on location 14: Single. Then cut, only 16 % of the most prominent American whiskey styles Worth Price. Is one of Scotlands first legal distilleries, the Macallan 12 Review: it! Of food trailblazers for 25 years Highland malts such as the 18 will based! Wash of around 8 % alcohol by volume ( ABV ) full flavor, the... And infinitely sip-able notes thanks to time patiently spent Highland Single Malt Scotch - 13 to 19 Yrs -.... 14 oban 14 vs macallan 12 old is another Highlander like the simple caramel and vanilla flavors, pick double oak continuous operation 1824... Loch three miles away difficult boss apparently creamy melon first, but the of!, top-selling Jim Beam the most prominent American whiskey styles whole area is made up old... The industry, and limit Obans production to just 650,000 liters of annually! Brands are the lightest in flavour ( pick only 1 ) Best Islay Scoth Ranked: the Original Malt! Are blends of different barrels a whisky tasting distilleries, the Macallan cooperage draws you in, & ;! Is bottled at 40 percent ABV, or Tomintoul Glenlivet, as they are the in. Match for the first round, but the warmth of the sherry oak compares to the Dalmore 12: Single. Oban distillery is owned by Diageo.It has only two pot stills, making one...